Saturday, February 21, 2009

History of a Soldier

A lot of my posts come from a listening journal I'm keeping as part of a class; please keep this in mind while reading the sometimes bookish parts. This is one of them from a few weeks back. The piece is "L'histoire du Suldat" by Igor Stravinsky.

Stravinsky’s ‘L’histoire du Soldat’ was written in 1918, and although Stravinsky was a composer of the modern period, Soldat is often considered the forerunner to his neo-classicist phase, as the piece makes use of short, conventional musical forms such as marches, popular dances (tango, waltz, ragtime) and chorales combined with modernisms’ extramusical agendas (creation of ‘national idioms’ in music, excavation and re-incarnations of ancient cultural traditions, etc.). Although still heavily dependent on Slavic folklore, dissonant harmonies and complex rhythms, Soldat features an objectivity and clarity that was typical of Classicism’s aesthetic, hence the neo-classicist tendencies. The piece’s orchestration is decidedly modern, featuring a septet of violin, double bass, clarinet, bassoon, cornet (trumpet), trombone and percussion (again, juxtaposing instrumentation preferred in popular genres with those of classical music, specifically the bassoon) in addition to the interaction of the septet with the actors’ Singspiel and Sprechgesang. By blurring the lines between music and drama, specifically through the use of popular song genres, Stravinsky no doubt laid the groundwork for composers and playwrites of the 20s and 30s such as Kurt Weill and Bertolt Brecht.
Based on a Russian folktale and making extensive use of archetypes prominent in Eastern Slavic folklore genres, Soldat tells the story of a soldier who trades his violin to the devil in exchange for a book that predicts the future, allowing the soldier to take advantage of future events for economic gain (an interesting twist to the Faustian tale, and incorporating the motif of the devil as a violinist/fiddler/musical archetype, i.e. Niccolo Paganini, ‘Death and the Maiden’ motifs in art and music, etc.). After loosing his former life, fiancé, and ability to play any violin thanks to the devil’s deception, he does quite well for himself and becomes a rich man. Eventually, he comes to realize that ‘one happy thing is every happy thing’, one can’t have it all (i.e. wealth and happiness, embodied in his violin/music) and figures out a way to trick the devil at his own game, marrying a princess in the process and regaining his music. In the end, his wife’s curiosity about his past causes them to return to the soldier’s home village, where on a technicality of Faustian legal principles, the devil regains control of the soldier’s soul.
This ending is very peculiar from a folkloric perspective. Devil characters are, to my knowledge, rare in Russian folklore, normally only existing as peripheral characters in stories and superstitions involving witches or other beings who work with/for the devil in return for extraordinary powers (generally, the devil would be part of a larger category of ‘evil spirits’ and wouldn’t necessarily resemble the devil of Christianity). What most Western cultures use the devil to explain, Russian folklore uses its grab-bag of spirits and creatures which survived the conversion of the pagan Slavs to Christianity in the eleventh century.
The devil’s place in folklore aside, if there where one folklore character who could out-smart the devil, it would have to be the soldier. The traditional imagination sees the soldier as a wise and worldly sort (having traveled and acquired many unique experiences during a lifetime in the army), always clever, crafty but a bit of a social outlier. This had a lot to do with laws and social customs related to conscription into the Tsar’s army and family inheritance patterns, respectively. In the serf system, landowners were required to supply the Imperial Army with bodies. Sometimes, if the family had aristocratic aspirations, they would send one of their own sons to become an officer, otherwise, the village would send one of its able bodied young men to serve as a noncommissioned officer. This fate was essentially a death sentence and all but guaranteed you would never see your home again. When you were drafted into the Army, the period of service was in excess of 25-30 (don’t know the exact number). Even if you managed not to get yourself killed, either by Russia’s enemies or malicious officers who still saw you as property in the serf system, the average life expectancy of the time (or now for that matter!) didn’t give the average boy enough time to be drafted, serve and ‘retire’ at home for any substantial period of time.
This fact wasn’t entirely without its practical implications. The form of inheritance practiced by Russian peasants divided the family’s land among all the sons in the family (it continued to be collectively owned and worked by the entire family, though, making this practice sustainable from an agricultural/economic perspective). If you were drafted, you essentially lost any claim to your family’s land since it was pretty much assumed that you wouldn’t live long enough to realize your father’s inheritance upon your return from service (and your brothers would always be more than happy to assume responsibility of your wealth/land). So basically, if you survived the army, you had nowhere to go. When one has nowhere to go, one goes any- and everywhere.
A lot of folk tales depict soldiers as beguiling and worldly in the sense of ‘street-smarts’, always able to trick or deceive characters of higher social status and intellectual abilities (normally not in a malicious way, rather in a survival sense. Soldiers had no home, land or family, so they are often depicted as being left to their own devices and having to fend for themselves). Therefore, if someone could get the best of the devil, it would have to be a soldier (or a ‘fool’ character, who always gets by on his dumb luck and simple-mindedness - think of Forest Gump). Soldat, therefore, strikes me as unique since, in the end, the devil actually out-smarts the soldier (thanks to the dumb wife’s curiosity. There’s also a lot of misogyny in traditional Russian culture). A lot of these inconsistencies could be explained by the fact that a Swiss-Frenchman adapted the folktale into a libretto, no doubt incorporating motifs of West-Central European folklore into his story.

Listening to Beethoven 5

Dear Friends,

This email serves first and foremost as an invitation to a concert I’m playing in this weekend with the Kansas City Civic Orchestra. On Sunday, February 22 at 2:00pm at the Folly Theater (300 W. 12th St., KCMO), we will be performing a Hungarian Dance from Berlioz’s “The Damnation of Faust”, a Rossini Bassoon concerto and Beethoven’s Symphony No. 5 in c minor. Beethoven’s 5th is without question the most widely recognized piece of Western classical music and represents for many people what classical music ‘is’ and ‘sounds like’. (if the name doesn’t sound familiar, say to yourself: da-da-da-DAAAAA; da-da-da-DAAAAA and you’ll know which piece I’m talking about). While we can all thank Beethoven for composing something that, in a manner of speaking, brings classical music to the masses, very few people can tell you what comes after those first four measures of da-da-da-DAAAA, or more importantly, why his 5th symphony is considered one of the most important pieces in the history of Western music. It was composed by a German at the beginning of the 19th century, but as was Beethoven’s wont, it speaks to the human race – past, present, and future: our joys, our passions and our struggle with this thing called ‘life’. Although I consider myself more musically informed than your average person, the larger importance of Beethoven’s 5th was unknown to me until I started rehearsing it in January. What follows is a summary of what I’ve learned about the 5th by reading what other scholars and musicians have written after studying Beethoven and his life (I’ve tried to weed out the boring and technical aspects typical of musicological writing). I’m taking up your time like this in the hopes that the piece will stir the same passion in you that it has in me, ultimately encouraging you to come to the concert this Sunday (did I mention it was free?).

Much love,
Mike

“…music is the one incorporeal entrance into the higher world of knowledge which comprehends mankind but which mankind cannot comprehend.” -attributed to Beethoven, 1810

This quote basically sums up why Beethoven is loved by and speaks to so many people, even if they aren’t fully conscience of why. I think what is implied here is that, while mankind may not be able to fully comprehend music, Beethoven gets music, and ipso-facto mankind. Beethoven reads us like a book, which is why his music speaks to our greatest joys and deepest fears, exposing our most hidden psychoses and foibles. One reason for this is because Beethoven disclosed so many of his own joys and problems in his music. Music is the most abstract of art forms; while the use of leitmotif does translate the emotional affect of a melody into concrete objects and people, symphonies are not novels and cannot be written exclusively with leitmotifs (a sort of musical equivalent of [proper] nouns). Music tells a different kind of story, which is emotional in the raw. If it’s a good musical ‘story’, then these emotions are universal – maybe not in an empathetic sense (not everyone has personally experienced the loss of a loved one, for example), but these emotions are definitely universal in the relative sense of how they affect us and make us feel. We all have demons, sorrows or some kind of a perceived fate that manifests itself differently to different people.
It’s this universal quality to Beethoven’s music which makes it speak to the whole of humankind, the 5th Symphony especially. The first four notes (da-da-da-daaaaaa) of the piece reoccur throughout all the movements, tap-tap-tap-tapping different notes and chords as Beethoven takes us on this journey. People like to quote Beethoven for explaining this motif as “Fate knocking on the door”. Very Romantic, right? Or maybe you say this is exceedingly problematic. What fate? Whose fate? Maybe you don’t believe in fate at all. Well, let’s see how Burnett James tackled this problem in his book Beethoven and Human Destiny:

“Because Beethoven’s sense of the fundamental life forces and his understanding of essential issues were more all-embracing and comprehensive, his conception of fate was at once simpler and more complex that than of the ordinary man – simpler because it could admit more easily of one universal definition, and more complex because it embraced the whole and did not deal in aspects only.”

Beethoven could accept that there are simultaneous and sometimes conflicting perceptions of what fate is/means to different people while recognizing that these interpretations are part and parcel of a larger whole – the ‘universal (idea of) fate’. But we still haven’t defined ‘fate’, have we? Is Beethoven envisioning three old ladies, one eye between then, holding a pair of scissors, just waiting to cut someone’s life string? I think not. Break it down, B.

“(quoting Schauffler) ‘Even if [the knocking on the door] conveys to the mind…a Goethean conception as fate supplanting the traditional wolf at the door, it may quite as reasonably convey entirely different things to a group of creative listeners unbiased by program annotations (program annotations/notes = the background and explanatory note that appear in the program fliers at concerts). [To some the fate motif] may signify a fierce conflict with a sexual obsession. [To others] a desperate campaign against an inferiority complex. [To others still] an old-fashioned pitched battle á la Paradise Lost between the forces of good and evil. To a victim of hysteria it may depict a war betweens sanity and bedlam. To a neurasthenic the struggle between those two mutually exclusive objectives: “To be or not to be?” To an evolutionist it may bring up the primordial conflict of fire and water, of man with beast, of civilization with savagery, of land with sea.’
There is obviously a confusion of thought here, and for the simple reason that the whole argument omits the preliminary definition of ‘fate’. Just as Schauffler argues elsewhere…that music may mean all things to all men, so fate manifests itself in one form to one individual and in another form to a different one…We are nearer to the mark if we follow Beethoven’s intimation that what is really involved here is a conflict between free will and determinism, between freedom and necessity.”

(i.e. one’s desire to be free from one’s demon – sexual obsession, mental illness, addiction to cigarettes, life’s ‘slings and arrows’/to be, etc. - and one’s basic need to indulge these demons or simply give up/not to be.

Thus, Beethoven’s view of fate resembled a struggle between humankind’s disposition to live freely/be self-determined and the agenda of ‘the powers that be’ (God, physical laws of the universe, social mores, or what-have-you) to put people in a box (housewife, paper-pushing beaurocrat, or, in a more physical and literal sense, a wooden box six feet underground). In this sense, Beethoven’s ‘fate’ is actually an articulation of the human condition to fight, to resist, to triumph in whatever way is personally meaningful and socially/psychologically required for an individual’s survival (If you’re still questioning Beethoven’s genius status, try putting him in an historical context. He was working through all these issues decades and centuries before Marx, Freud, Jung, Weber, Durkheim, Foucault, de Tocqueville and many others).
Beethoven’s motto was ‘Freedom above all’ – artistic freedom, political freedom, personal freedom of will, of art, of faith, freedom of the individual in all the aspects of life. I think we can agree that those who so vehemently advocate freedom often do so because they have personally witnessed or experienced oppression (in a very broad sense of the word for the purposes of our discussion). So, what was Beethoven’s baggage? Here’s the short list:
From an early age, he was exploited (and some think physically and psychologically abused) by his father, Johann, who wanted him to be the next Wunderkind of Europe, a sensation like Mozart before him.
Romantic difficulties, unrequited love and a marriage sabotaged by his would-be father-in-law. Beethoven never married.
Politically disappointed. Beethoven’s 3rd Symphony, also called the Eroica (Heroic) was originally dedicated to Napoleon because Ludwig was so taken by the enlightened promises of Napoleon’s reign. That was until his imperial ambitions became clear and Beethoven scratched out the original dedication and wrote instead “Dedicated to the Memory of a Heroic Man”.
Deafness. He began to loose his hearing in 1796, thanks to a severe form of tinnitus – a ringing in his ears that overtime increased in severity and made it difficult for him to perceive music. It also caused him to shy away from conversation, and (presumably) in turn, the outside world.

With this in mind, his 5th Symphony is where Beethoven makes his stand against the oppressive forces in his life. He once wrote in a letter to a good friend, ‘I will take Fate by the throat; it shall not wholly overcome me’. The Fifth symbolizes this fight, stranglehold and ultimate triumph; while a maniac father, villainous (would-be) father-in-law and deafness (at the time of the Fifth’s composition, Beethoven may have been able to convince himself that his deteriorating hearing was merely temporary and surmountable) may have been the real-life struggles that spawned the symphony, the piece describes the fight that everyone wages with themselves and their place in society. (Also of note is the Symphony’s key signature, c minor. Scholars say that C is a key that Beethoven personally identified with, especially when he was in a ‘heroic’ state of mind. The switching between C major and minor could depict Beethoven the Hero fighting a battle).

Here the breakdown of Fate and resistance in the Symphony movement-by-movement (please note, this is just how I see/hear things):
Movement I: Fate knocks and takes us totally by surprise. “The listener is immediately thrown into an unknown situation – and not by a mysterious and enticing piece of ambiguity but by that most unsettleing of all utterances, the imperious command to do one knows not what…The listener is irrevocably drawn into Beethoven’s drama with this opening that is more a direct command than an exhortation”. It is a challenge to the self, a command – the invasive expression of a will. This is ‘Geisterfurcht’ (dread of spirits/specters); “this spirit arrives without invitation, without warning, and its message is baleful”. One can think of the oboe solo as Beethoven pleading with Fate for mercy. Fate doesn’t listen (i.e. the orchestra plays on in its ominous, minor key attack).
Movement II: Fate seems to have taken a holiday. We’re in a major key, meandering through a triumphant melody, a sort of reverie.
Movement III: Fate was just biding its time. It creeps back in the opening lines, once again in a minor key. This subtlety is quickly replaced by a sort of hide-and-go-seek dancing battle between Fate and our hero. About halfway through, the fugue (in major) is where the real battle begins. The battle ends ambiguously; we don’t know if our hero has triumphed. There’s a calm after the storm as the dust settles and we go directly into
Movement IV: We’ve finally made it into a triumphal major key. Our hero has won! There’s hope for us in our personal struggles yet! Hurra!

If you’re still reading at this point, I hope I’ve been able to entice you to come to the concert this Sunday, or at the very least go out to the library and find a recording.